Monday, June 15, 2009

Newspapers "For the People" - A Prescription for Change?

In this article, a journalism professor offers suggestions for the Boston Globe and for newspapers in general. Do you agree or disagree with his ideas? Do newspapers stand a chance?

6 comments:

  1. While I do agree with his 3 suggestions, I do not think it will save the newspaper. Why would someone pay for an outdated newspaper when they could read current news online for free? Those 3 tips are probably things newspapers should be doing anyways. I'm not sure when but the newspaper will eventually become extinct.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Rhea Friesen--
    Points 2 and 3 are on the right track, but ms1497 has a point—that should be what is going on regardless. The article seems to lack new insight. People want to be catered to on a different level now—one that is higher than this article recognizes.

    Newspapers have a problem and it’s today’s consumers. Consumers today expect to see only the information they want when they want it…and rightly so. Technology being what it is.

    It’s not likely that a purely printed medium can provide instant gratification. Ever. So printed media has to focus on catering to the only-information-they-want aspect. This poses a problem because each individual is different and wants different things. No one can ever know exactly what a person wants to read at any given time except that person.

    Perhaps different versions of a newspaper could be made and surveys could be done to find which demographic group should get which paper. This could easily lead to discrimination and an intentional neglect of certain news to certain demographics.

    What if people went through and picked what types of stories they would like to see? This could be too cumbersome for print, but would work well on the Internet. Just a few clicks on a survey and ta-da—better yet, when a reader sees an article on the computer they could be given the option to click “like” or “dislike” to make minute changes to the original survey. Pandora did it with music. So, why not? If people want to save their paper for the day they could special order it.

    One thing print has and will always have over any other media is entity. An article that questions the executive branch (for example) can’t be unprinted, but it can easily be deleted or adjusted in an online source—just a few key strokes. Online, as quickly as information can be gained, it can be taken away. Then where is your proof? The reporter has gone missing—too bad.

    The future for newspapers does look bleak but not empty.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Lara Crouch
    I agree the newspapers should already be doing Professor Lanson's three points. I also agree with Rhea that the news in the paper cannot be unprinted and news on the internet can be missed.
    The newspaper still stands a chance because it still is the watchdog for the people and the community. The newspaper has more credibility than the piling articles piecing together information on the internet. The newspaper brings it all together for a local, broader audience.

    ReplyDelete
  4. When Lanson speaks of roots, it reminds me of that saying "You don't know where you're going unless you know where you've been." This holds true to newpspapers in their economic decline.

    I agree with Lanson's prescription for newspapers and believe it should be taken seriously because the fact is, there has been more layoffs and more premature closures of newspapers than I would like to see as a Mass Comm. major.

    I agree that we shouldn't give readers "yesterday's news." However, if it provides a different angle or viewpoint then it should be considered news. You can talk about General Motors all week long, but focus on the families it's affected, the communities, not just the economy. It just makes it a different kind of news that people can still relate to.

    Lanson's advice was obvious to say the least, but the part that struck me as critical was the last two words --the people.

    The people that built this nation into the mess it has become. And what we need to realize is that newspapers were and still are the medium that brings massive people together in times of turmoil. When nations are at war, when government is corrupt, when ordinary people need their voice heard, newspapers are there to give them a platform.

    I think it should not only be respected, but protected because if newspapers were to become obsolete, how will THE PEOPLE hold anyone accountable? And that is the scariest thought to think about.

    The fact is, newspapers have protected us so it is our right to protect them. The 1st Amendment is a powerful thing and the survival of newspapers for this long shows its proof.

    I may be part of the Generation Y sweep of news technology, but I'm also a traditional and proud American. Take a hard look back.

    LONG LIVE NEWSPAPERS!

    ReplyDelete
  5. I agree with mel and how if newspapers were to become obsolete, how would the people hold anyone accountable. The newspapers have always provided a more reliable and concrete source that Americans have depended on for years. And now as the online surge is taking place more people can just write anything which to many people is seen as the truth. I think Lanson's three suggestions are valid in how to save the newspaper. I think newspapers should go back to their roots and focus on how whats going on in the world and how it is affecting people locally.The newspaper should have stories that everyone can relate to and can bring many together on an issue. Like Lanson said newspapers should have a strong voice of leadership and stand up for what they believe in and not conform to what people in elite status think. They should be bringing communities together on issues that could benefit them. The Internet is useful for fast news but it doesn't have the ability to engage a reader to take action on certain issues that interest them like the newspaper can. The newspaper should give the common people a voice without the government influencing it and having control over it. Newspapers need to get back to having stories that benefit the common person and not just try to appease the government. I think the newspaper will survive through this transition but they have to change the current way they have been doing things like Lanson said

    ReplyDelete
  6. I agree with most of the comments above and honestly, I would prefer to read a newspaper in print than online. Yes, online is easier, but it's just not the same. After the older generation dies off, and the new technologically savvy generation steps in, I'm not sure if print will survive. Apparently there needs to be a change in newspapers because so many are falling through. They need to relate to the new generation. I think the three points need to be put into action.

    ReplyDelete